by Ian Enterline
Channel 12 has this story on “Why Mercyhurst Helps Erie” by giving the city money in lieu of taxes. As a non-profit, the school is not required to pay taxes, but they have given the city $500,000 over three years. Gannon hasn’t given anything, and seems like it is being attacked for not doing so, and Mercyhurst people are patting themselves on the back:
Dr. Thomas Gamble, President of Mercyhurst College, says although the college is not obligated to pay, they believe they’re being good neighbors.
“We have this symbiotic relationship with the city. Clearly we use police and fire, the sewers, everything. And so we do have a symbiotic relationship. When the city does well, Mercyhurst does better. When Mercyhurst does well, the city does better. And because of that relationship, that mutuality of that relationship, we thought that it was a good thing to do.”
Yip, yip-yahoo.
The fact of the matter is, at almost $12,ooo a semester per student, Mercyhurst is making money hand-over fist. So what do they do? Stop having the 4th of July Celebration, and give the City that$500,000. In reality, it is only about $167,000 each year. As often as the fire department runs alarms up there, or drunken students tear up the local neighborhood - this isn’t nearly enough money to cover the usage of city services.
Then, since they don’t have enough on-campus student housing, “property investors” buy houses in the local neighborhood and rent them to the students, who are more than willing to get drunk and literally run rampant. Try driving down East 38th Street on a Friday or Saturday night from around 11 pm to 2 or 3 in the morning and you will see what I’m talking about.
On top of that, the City is not even listening to the concerns of the citizens already living in these neighborhoods. As far as the City is concerned, the problems that Mercyhurst students cause are easily ignored because the college gives them a measily $167,000 a year. And Mercyhurst could really care less as well, they can easily say that anything that happens off-campus is not their problem. And this is the truth, as far as it goes.
But if they really wanted to “be a good neighbor”, maybe they need to start listening to their neighbors.
I live in Richmond, VA and work as a firefighter, but I try to make as many trips back to Erie is as humanly and financially feasible.
Mixing Erie and politics can be dicey, but I'm gonna try to do it here!
Vito Randazzo
September 14th, 2008 at 5:23 pm
Ian,
As a myself being a “Non-Traditional” student of the hurst, I can see your point of view espically for the amount of tutition they charge. I agree with your point of view that the concerns of city residents shouldn’t be ignored in the face of $$$$$, but it’s unfortuntate but thats what this world revolves around money. They say “money talks, bullshit walks”.
I disagree with you on the point of what does Mercyhurst contribute to the community, with the exception of the whole donation/4th july fiasco. I think mercyhurst gives local students a chance to earn a an excellent education, which I know several people whom have graduated from the hurst and have been successful in erie and contributed to the community. Yes, they work in erie, unfortunately thats not a common thing which I will leave for a future dicussion.
Mikey Z
September 14th, 2008 at 8:10 pm
Yeah Ian you forget the vital contribution of drunk college chicks that Mercyhurst makes to the Erie community every Thursday thru Saturday night. The young horny male population of Erie is quite grateful for this valuable service.
bojosmom
September 15th, 2008 at 3:14 am
Am I to infer from your critique of the current Payment In Lieu of Taxes system with Mercyhurst and other non-profits that you would prefer the payment of services suggestion that Emma of Eriepressible suggested?
There’s really no getting around the college student immaturity as far as drunken behavior goes. The same behavior is observed downtown with Gannon University students. I think the folks in Edinboro may be on the right track with enacting ordinances limiting student housing and promoting inspections as part of a way to curb bad behaviour and appease neighborhood residents. What say you?
Mark
September 15th, 2008 at 11:50 am
I don’t see why so much hate is directed towards Mercyhurst College when the problem truly is the neighbors living in the area. One of the reasons the Fourth of July Celebration left the Hurst was because the neighbors (not all of the neighbors) complained about the traffic and lack of parking. Garbage was an issue, but you would think that once a year these “neighbors” could deal with picking up their yard.
Another reason the neighbors are a problem is because Mercyhurst is buying every house that goes up for sale in the area. Mercyhurst wants to expand, it has the potential, the academic programs are amongst the best, but it does not have the land, leading to the purchasing of these houses. Yes, you can make the argument that some of these residents have been living around campus for years, but if the problem is such a problem, “why haven’t they left?”
Mercyhurst College has a beautiful campus. If you disagree I suggest you talk a walk thru it. The trees, the architecture, and the people are wonderful, but what Mercyhurst needs is for the Citizens of Erie to support there cause. Back when 38th street was realigned I thought Erie was in the right direction in regards to promoting Mercyhurst. The new 38th street might be more convenient driving wise, but it’s a disgrace to look at. The weeds are atrocious. Why not promote 38th street as the link between Mercyhurst College and Penn State Behrend?
As for the drunken students on 38th street-drive around any college campus on a Friday or Saturday night and you will find college kinds stumbling around. That’s what college kids do. College is a great experience; don’t put u barriers, put up boundaries. A little give and take from each side of the problem will lead to conflict resolution.
Looking at Erie we see a nice middle class town with three great higher educational institutes that promote individualized growth. Why not promote these schools? By promoting these schools these schools will grow. With growth comes business and with business comes opportunity, something Erie has lacked for all too long.
Melissa
September 15th, 2008 at 1:21 pm
I lived on Grandview Ave three years ago, on the south end of the campus. I lived in a complex that had a number of Hurst, Behrend, and Gannon students. For all the hype about “bad behavior” I didn’t see much of it on evening and weekend walks around the campus or down to the Cornerstone. I’m not denying that it goes on - it does - but in comparison to other colleges, the Hurst is really mild.
I’d say instead of bashing the campus as a whole (becuase Mercyhurst has some excellent programs and successful alumni) enact better punishment for drunken behavior, vandalism, or trespassing. Much of this can be accomplished by the college itself. I’m sure it has a judicial board (Behrend does). Unfortunately, such systems create a “bubble.” Students may not be punished as they should in reality. Impose heftier punishment and resort to expulsion when necessary. The college simply can’t allow students to be living in a “bubble.” Punishment needs to be more representative of the real world.
Tim
September 15th, 2008 at 1:53 pm
Mercyhurst was just trying to make Gannon look bad, that’s all! WICU had an interview with the Gannon CFO who was quoted as saying “we don’t contribute money to Erie because some of our donors would find it objectionable.” Basically Gannon wants to keep all their donors happy…more money for them. It is becoming problematic their purchase of a lot of prime downtown Erie real estate. The purchase of the Verizon building (for instance) means that Erie will lose around $350,000 a year in tax revenues.
At least Mercyhurst is helping out Erie. Gannon could do more to help out but doesn’t want to for whatever reason.
As for the drunk females on the weekend…just tell me where they are and I’ll make the drinks! LOL
Ian Enterline
September 15th, 2008 at 4:13 pm
Mark, I never said that their campus wasn’t nice, I’ve walked through it more times than you can count. And, I’m not saying that they don’t have excellent academic programs, they do. And I’m not saying that the citizens don’t support their cause. I’m saying that someone needs to take responsibility for what’s going on off campus.
By the way, Mercyhurst is not buying these houses. They are being bought up by people who rent them out to the college kids. They are not properly maintained, and are a blight to what is actually a fairly nice neighborhood. Speaking of which, having lived in that neighborhood, I don’t know of too many people who lived there that complained about the 4th of July Celebration, to be quite honest. To try to blame that on the neighbors is just utterly ridiculous. In fact, I would say that most people looked forward to it.
As far as boundaries v. barriers, try telling the difference to the couple that I know having their light post torn down by college students, or the people having sex out in the open in the backyard of these student houses (I’ve seen it myself). They created bedrooms for that.
If Mercyhurst and the City of Erie would be more responsive to the needs of the neighborhood, then maybe the citizens would more readily support the college and it’s activities.
Tim
September 15th, 2008 at 5:19 pm
Sex in a backyard!!!??? That’s one wild college neighborhood!
Ian Enterline
September 15th, 2008 at 6:42 pm
Yes, sex in a backyard. I would tell the story here, but it would be more appropriate for a porn site!
Tim
September 15th, 2008 at 7:33 pm
That’s a good idea for a website:
http://www.BackyardCollegeNymphos.com LOL!!!!!!!!
Dan
September 21st, 2008 at 7:13 pm
I think the city of Erie slapped GU in the face when they ok’d the halfway
(criminal release) house on the doorstep of GU’s campus. Gu also has its own police dept that ppatrols the campus. The students have contributed over 72,000 hrs of community service. While MC keeps moving out of the city (NE & Girard), can you imagine if GU would stop ivesting in downtown Erie? Ghost town?