by Peter Panepento
Just to prove how open I am, I’ve chosen an analogy to the Boston Red Sox (gulp) as our comment of the week.
There were plenty of great choices this week, as the site really bubbled with some great commentary on issues such as public libraries and Erie’s mindset.
But I’m singling out a comment from Michael because it illustrates rather colorfully an issue I’ve been pushing quite a bit lately. Here it is:
Erie is like the Red Sox. The Red Sox kept failing to win the World Series for 86 years, and the fans seemed to almost revel in their losing. I think the population of Erie is similar. They’ve accepted the “same old” that happens, almost expecting it, and gripe about it constantly.
And as the other posters said, the local government is part of this. The Red Sox for years used the same formula of having a offensive fixture in left field (See Williams, Yaz, Rice, Manny) around a good lineup and then skimping on speed, defense, or relief pitching- this was the Red Sox for years. They were even the last team to have a black player — they stuck to their old ways and lost for most of the 50’s and 60’s rather than embrace the change that every other team in the league had,
The Red Sox finally realized a few years ago that maybe they should embrace the things they needed, an abandon the way they ran their franchise for years. They brought in Theo Epstein, a twenty-something who had been a Yale law student, as their GM. They brought in statistics guru Bill James. They put more of a focus on defense and speed. It has paid off with two World Series Championships. They spent all that time focusing on the big bad Yankees, but the Yankees never held them back. They did. They never changed and seemingly expected to lose in the end, and that’s what always happened for 86 years.
Erie has the same problem as the old Red Sox. Leaders that all seem to be cut from the same mold. The same ideas. The public accepting the same ideas. Not embracing the changing times. The bad attitude filtering everywhere.
Erie can change, but the “old ways” need to be abandoned and change needs to be embraced- change in our leaders and change in our attitude.
Einstein once said, “The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.”
After more than six years working as a journalist in Erie, I'm now the web editor for the Chronicle of Philanthropy in Washington, D.C., and the publisher of GlobalErie.com. I still maintain close ties to Erie - a community that I care about deeply. I hope this Web site can help inspire a better future for Erie.
TJ
November 14th, 2008 at 10:11 pm
I understand the point but the needed change in leadership starts with voters.
DougB
November 15th, 2008 at 7:17 pm
Peter, There is hope for you yet.
George Vietze
November 17th, 2008 at 5:52 pm
Envision Erie meetng Nov. 18.,5:30 PM -Erie Art Museum Annex.
Join this community group and shape your community.
Join Renee Lamis and others as they discuss how best to help take Erie and Erie County to its destiny as the NW Hub of Pa.,become part of the solution.
Kevin Smith
November 22nd, 2008 at 10:39 am
I have to say, it is great to see community groups that care so much about the future of the this region. Although, I feel these types of groups are critical, I also feel the real change needs to come from small and mid sized businesses. I agree, there is a “Boston Red Sox Mentality”, but that mentality is deep seeded into many of the small businesses in the region as well; and that twill continue to be boulder that these small community groups will be faced with pushing.
The mentality and culture of small business owners drive the mentality and culture of the entire region. On a “micro” level, consider an employer who, instead of reflecting an unwavering drive for excellence and developing a champion mindset in his or her employees, simply broadcasts is conformance to the ideal that local government and the national economy is holding his company back. That mentality is contagious and spreads to the employees who come home everyday and spreads it to their spouses, which is then embedded in the minds of the children, who ultimately graduate from college and leave our community.
Now that is certainly an abridged version, but the point is still the same. Leadership is not concrete. You can’t put it in a box and sell it, so many manager and business owners don’t put much stock in developing leaders within their organizations. I have spoken with many small business owners in the Erie area, and many (I don’t want to generalize) of them have absolutely no hope that their business can strive and grow. Many of them are content to remain in their comfort zone and remain small, blissfully unaware that without growth, an economical shift can take them out of business altogether.
As a community, there is a great danger in putting all of our economical eggs in one or two baskets. We can’t count on GE to be our economical foundation. We need to look no further than Corry PA to see the consequences of what can happen when that basket breaks. I suggest that small and medium sized business must excel in this region before significant change in individual mindset can be made.
I could go on forever about that, and how some of the business support organizations have failed small businesses in the region, but that will solve nothing. I will instead, as I hope most others will, opt for a positive attitude towards making things better. I will jump off my pulpit and just conclude by saying that I will be bringing in fresh faces and dynamic individuals form outside the region to speak to local business owners as long as there is an audience. This is not to suggest that we don’t have very dynamic and positive small business owners here in the region. I just feel we need a new perspective to supplement local insight. We need to know what it is that we don’t know and do something different.
Dr. William A. Cohen, Major General USAF (retired), will be addressing local business owners on this very subject on March 26th, 2009. If any members of Team Erie would be interested in attending, I would be happy to provide more info. Marketing for the event will begin in late December.
I would be happy to be a part of any community effort that has a concrete mission and agenda and is willing to do what it takes to execute.
Kevin S Smith
Keystone Business Forum